Early in the COVID-19 pandemic, Congress created the Provider Relief Fund (PRF) to help providers respond to the crisis, with funds distributed by the Health Resources and Services Administration (HRSA). Because PRF requirements evolved throughout the pandemic, it is not surprising that a recent Office of Inspector General (OIG) audit of the $19.3 billion Phase 3 distribution found that nearly half of sampled payments were either calculated incorrectly or lacked sufficient supporting documentation, such as tax returns or audited financial statements.
Across the statistical and non-statistical samples reviewed, OIG identified $658 million in potential overpayments and $131.3 million in underpayments. OIG indicated the overpayment errors were the result of, “… HRSA made payments: (1) without subtracting prior payments made to providers’ subsidiary organizations; (2) based on incorrect information entered on providers’ PRF applications; (3) based on incorrect patient care revenues, expenses, or both; and (4) based on the incorrect loss ratio.”
OIG recommended that HRSA review the providers identified as potentially overpaid, determine actual overpayment amounts, and seek repayment where appropriate. HRSA neither concurred nor non-concurred with the recommendations, citing concerns about some OIG calculations for at least 10 of the sampled providers. HRSA said that, to the extent resources are available, it will review supporting documentation for the remaining 46 sampled providers identified by HRSA as overpaid to determine whether OIG’s findings align with HRSA policy and pursue repayment, as appropriate. It also noted that more than $324M has already been repaid by two of the sampled providers.
It is important to keep these over-payments in perspective. Even if they are confirmed, they represent roughly 3.4% of the total funds distributed in Phase 3, which is a low error rate for a program that was stood up quickly during a public health emergency to help providers weather the storm. Nonetheless some providers may have some of their PRF dollars recouped.